XR shenanigans 

Someone's talking about taming capitalism lmao

LOL at the groups that ignore my suggestions of switching to decentralised social media platforms (wink wink, Fediverse) because "everyone uses Facebook", but in the same breath curse at how they've been shadow banned by the very same platform for MONTHS now. No one sees their posts because the platform they are on is working against them. The solution is so bloody clear...

XR, - , (Cambridge, UK) 

The XR Youth, and the more woke folks in XR, are struggling to get the "problematic" folks on board and are spending a lot of time dealing with them instead of making progress with the actual aims of the organisation. XR Cambridge desperately needs restructuring because a number of highly concentrated nodes of power have developed over the year, and attempts to dissolve those nodes has been met with resistance.

XR :pika_surprise: 

Yes, this is XR, albeit only a local group. From minutes of a recent meeting.

"There was a suggestion here that Tories and racists should be accepted (encouraged) in the group"

The XR Youth are planning a disruption of the next XR meeting.


This is from a Google doc of XR's Global demands:
"All people and all life are united by the will to survive and the desire to pass on the flame of life undimmed. It is in that sense that the emergency situation we now face is “Beyond Politics”. Our survival depends on countering the financial interests that are weaponising race and class to divide us, and in coming together in solidarity, from left to right and from North to South."

If saying the left and right should kiss and make up is to appeal to people without proper political understanding, then that's bad because XR will attract people without political understanding. If they genuinely believe what they're writing, that's bad because it's just another case of XR not having a fucking clue.

And I don't really feel that the exploited global south should be showing solidarity with the north after being drained of profits.

Getting panicky now the fires are rising? They've been burning people in other countries for decades.

XR - 

XR's statement of 3.5% mobilisation of the population as a level at which a movement will be successful is based on a book co-authored by Maria Stephan, who was the lead foreign affairs officer in the US State Department’s Bureau of Conflict and Stabilization Operations (CSO) when the book was published.

She sites Mark Palmer as a "great mentor". He was co-founder and board director of the National Endowment for Democracy (NED) whose role is to foment nonviolent movements against almost any government which challenges or defies the United States, questions the value of unrestrained capitalism, limits the rights of foreign corporations, or adopts policies that the US consider socialist.

The NED had a hand in the coup in Bolivia, putting money into the right wing parties and spreading discontent.

I don't feel like these are the people we should be trusting to inform a rebellion.



Die Zeit interview with Roger Hallam, the co-founder of Extinction Rebellion UK:

Leaked plan written by Hallam after Die Zeit interview:

Public statement from Hallam for journalists after Die Zeit interview:

Public apology from Hallam posted on Facebook after Die Zeit interview:

Interview with Spiegel that partially covers the Die Ziet interview:

Public XR UK statement on XR UK's views on Hallam's remarks:

Damn, Earth First is right on:

"While many organisations and spaces rightfully try to make themselves more welcoming to marginalised people through a ‘safer spaces’ policy that opposes oppressive or bigoted behaviour, we believe they create a false sense of security. People tacitly agree to these ‘policies’ whilst not actually undertaking the work in making meaningful changes to their own behaviour. This may be because of denial, guilt or ignorance."

This describes so many people in XR so well!


XR, leaking 

This is a paragraph written by Gail Bradbook in draft document being written up by XR Central at the moment:

"We must however resist moves to co-opt our movement into an 'intersectional, anti-capitalist' focussed movement based on alternative (potentially unclear) theories of change. Not because we are not deeply sympathetic with addressing oppression, colonisation and the systemic problems in the economy. Rather we seek to open space for dialogue, to base our culture on no shaming and blaming and we don’t think that left wing style messaging does generally inspire community involvement, at least we won’t assume it does."

My local XR group have bought a bunch of bad, climate related meme stickers to stick around the city in protest...

We are willing to commit time and effort to meet with all relevant internal parties to take action together. We are grateful that we also have so many allies within and outside XR supporting us. We are also grateful for the contributions of all PoC who are trying to change the XR narrative through a variety of initiatives and actions.

We cannot change what brought us here, but we can change where we go from here.

Let’s do this together.

Show thread

• Many actions continue without accountability. This actively harms marginalised voices in XR. For example, our voices were not heard on the Canning Town/Shadwell actions (we asked to distance ourselves from it beforehand; afterwards other PoC asked that we openly condemn the actions due to the violence involved at CT). Another example is cofounders’ promotion of arrest, which has been dismissed as something that cannot be countered. We ask why these actions/voices continue to represent us, when they simply cannot and should not represent or speak for us. We ask for accountability and, where we are unable to take these issues forward ourselves, for allies to help to address these specific concerns.

Show thread

• That effective systems are put in place for checks and balances against implicit power, and that PoC are included in their formulation, to help mitigate the risks of ‘blind spots’ which so clearly arose through the Canning Town/Shadwell actions.

• For groups to recognise the absence of people of colour and those from other marginalised groups and show some dedication to finding out why that is. We do not want tokenistic representation, but honest exploration of the implicit power relationships that lead to situations of non-inclusion.

Show thread

We recognise that some work is being carried out to build this into XR, e.g. through anti oppression workshops. However, ongoing evaluation and feedback must become core toway we strategise and act. It should become part of our work in local, affinity and all other groups. It should be part of DNA and of SOS. Unless this becomes embedded in the waydo things we will fail to build a truly inclusive mass movement.

We are a group of people of colour who are clear in our commitment to XR and we believe we have a fundamental role to play in addressing some of the useful and insightful criticisms that have recently arisen. Our commitment to XR means we will also fiercely defend it from criticism that is not useful or that seeks to use our internal struggles as a way to divide XRa movement. We raise only a few key points here. Moving forward, we suggest the following actions.

Show thread

By messaging arrest as the ‘right’ way to rebel, it undermines the other key elements of XR rebel culture that can help to build a mass movement. Both MLK and Gandhi spent significant time looking internally at their own beliefs, biases and values. Nonviolence was not just a strategy, but a way of life centred around inner work. Whilst we recognise that XR’s Theory of Change is centred on non-violence as a strategic aim rather than way of(based on e.g the writings of Paul and Mark Engler and Gene Sharp), this itself is centreda Western way of thinking that breaks down the whole into parts for extraction and appropriation purposes.

Show thread

Regenerative Culture

Though arrest is core to XR’s Theory of Change, there are parallel strategies that need to co-exist and mutually reinforce one another. Looking to the successful movements of both Mohandas Gandhi and Martin Luther King (MLK), these were built from the grassroot level by the people already suffering. Fundamentally, they were in touch and in tune with the suffering of people and built varied strategies and actions that enabled mass participation.

Show thread

• Data disclosed by the Metropolitan Police in August 2017 found that people of African descent and of ethnic minority background, in particular young African and Caribbean men, are subject to deadly use of force by restraint, and are twice as likely to die after the use of force by police officers. The Government’s own publications indicate that black people are over three times as likely to be arrested as white people.

• Black people are also 91⁄2 times more likely to be stopped and searched than white people, according to 2017/18 figures.

• Self-harm in prison in England and Wales has reached record highs in the 12 months running up to March 2019, up 24% from the previous 12 months. In the most recent quarter, self-harm incidents increased by 1% to 14,415 incidents.

• The Lammy Review also points to a disparity in custodial treatment, to the detriment of people of colour.

Show thread

To move forward, we need to learn and recognise that existing structural inequalities within our society impact upon peoples’ capacity to engage actively in one of the key strategies of rebellion, namely arrestability. To simplify and promote an individual positive experience of prison endorses and perpetuates a flawed and structurally unequal system. It undermines the experiences of the many people who have suffered and died in jail, who are harmed by the system and treated differently. Above all it ignores the point that an experience of positive treatment is a hallmark of privilege.

For anyone with high levels of implicit power to call the prison experience positive is problematic and dangerous. Prison ruins people's lives, as some of the statistics below highlight.

Show thread


We were therefore very disappointed to see Roger’s Facebook post last week. After the actions of Canning Town and Shadwell, we had hoped that those who have power within XR - perceived leaders, co-founders and coordinators - would become more attuned to the issues that PoC, including PoC in XR face in relation to race and inequality. We had hoped that they would become more mindful of, and responsible towards, the authority they wield in this regard in influencing, leading, and representing the actions of many people in XR.

We encourage coordinators, leaders and founders of XR to become aware of the damage that poorly constructed messages around arrest creates. We recognise the work that some XR groups are already carrying out in support of this, such as International Solidarity Network, Connecting Communities, XR Together and XR Liberation.

Show thread
Show more
Sunbeam City 🌻

Sunbeam City is a Libertarian Socialist solarpunk instance. It is ran democratically by a cooperative of like-minded individuals.