Think I might live toot 'The Young Karl Marx' movie, it looks just generic enough to be funny

Ok so it started with Marx reading an article from his Young Hegelian days, it cuts to him arrogantly saying "I know what's best" and dismissing their ideas as vague (which they are)

Then Marx interrupts Proudhon during a lecture and goes over all the usual tropes beat for beat.

Show thread

Meanwhile Engels is being an incel creeping on the workers his father fired.

Marx meets Engels and they almost immediately start sucking each other's work off. There's a chase scene out of fucking nowhere as cops chase the two through Paris (I'm so confused)

Show thread

Oh wow, the editing in this film is really bad, its shots don't match, the audio is sliced together in beat with the video cuts so it's really obvious when they're stitching two different takes together.

Show thread

Oooh Karl Marx is having nightmare/flashbacks now

And boring philosophers are talking boring philosophy in period mise-en-scene

This movie is... Odd...

Show thread

Oh fuck... This film really subscribes to the great man theory of history, this isn't good...

Show thread

They're just calling eachother great men, then politely insulting eachother and giving speeches to workers.

Every other scene shows these people literally talking down to workers, even when not giving grand speeches.

Show thread

This movie is really dark... Not in terms of the tone, but in terms of TURN THE FUCKING LIGHTS ON OR COLOUR GRADE THIS MOVIE PROPERLY FUCK

Show thread

"We live in a society!"


It just had a scene where Marx, Engels and Engels' wife all calmly and politely told off a posh person for exploiting children.

This is hilarious.

Show thread

Aaaaand Marx is going off on a "Poor people are stupid" take again, someone punch him please

Show thread

It's the 1840s and they're already trying to split the left. Why are tankies like this?😹

Show thread

So I'm at the 2nd act lowpoint, Engels and Marx have been kicked out of some socialist group, looks like their plan isn't going to work... Whatever it is.

I'm 2/3rds of the way through the movie, and I can't confidently say what its plot is...

Show thread

HAHAHA there's a fucking montage of them writing bullshit! This is the least exciting montage I have ever fucking seen!

Show thread

They're writing a critique of Proudhon's new book for... Why? What reason exactly? I have no idea what their motivation is in the context of this movie...

Show thread

AHAHAHAHHA! They just had a guy get up on stage to interrupt Engels and preach Nonviolence, out of fuckin nowhere, who is this guy?

Omg... This is one of the hokiest acted speeches I've ever seen

Show thread

They just pulled down the banners and launched a coup, forming the Communist league. Anarchists v Marxists line drawn down the middle. Still don't know why these characters are doing anything they're doing. Things just seem to happen in succession.

The editing is really really fucking weird, I don't know what's going on anymore

Show thread

Now Marx and Engels are arguing for no reason, why? Why is any of this happening?

Show thread

Oh no... They're going to end it with them publishing the manifesto, fuck

Show thread

They're literally just reading the Communist Manifesto over a montage of sad proletarians looking directly at the camera. A little girl in front of a french flag stares at the camera as it fades to black and says "The 1848 revolution started one month later" then recounts what they go on to do.

You can practically see the director wanking behind the camera...

And for some reason the credits music is "Like a Rolling Stone" played over a nonsensical montage of class struggle throughout the years.

Show thread

In conclusion, its "plot" meanders, going absolutely nowhere and flat-out dropping plot threads and picking others out of nowhere.

The movie is *apparently* about the beginning of the conflict between Marxists and Anarchists, but we're never quite shown why this conflict is happening. Marx and Engels, in the context of the film, have absolutely zero motivation for doing what they're doing. Proudhon happily hands them his book, and instantly they're in a weak montage writing their response... why? I don't fucking know!

Anarchists are broadly displayed as dogmatic of and subservient to Proudhon, whereas Marxists literally talking down to the proletariat are given this "great man" status. (Even alleging that they were responsible for the 1848 revolutions)

The editing is shockingly bad, none of the cuts have any motivation, shots have no connection to one another, scenes just begin and end out of nowhere, giving tonal and pacing whiplash.

Bad movie. Bad bad bad.

Show thread

@GreenandBlack we live in a society - karl marx and friedrich engels, the communist manifesto


They're jealous of how all Anarchists get free overcoats.

@GreenandBlack wtf I need to watch this movie now. It sounds like Tommy Wiseau as a tankie

@GreenandBlack Marx/Engels
Tags: hurt/comfort, angst, minor character death, rough sex, fluff, communism, b

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Sunbeam City 🌻

Sunbeam City is a Libertarian Socialist solarpunk instance. It is ran democratically by a cooperative of like-minded individuals.